Who holds the forest, and does it change what happens to it?
A lecture page for forestry students (UBC FRST 370). It compares how Canada and Brazil write down who decides, then reads one Brazilian case, Bacurizinho in Maranhão, with forty years of satellite records, and says at each step what the result does and does not mean.
How to cite: Biondo, Leandro M. (2026). Who holds the forest, and does it change what happens to it? UmaTerra. https://umaterra.com.br/en/stories/forest-tenure-lecture/
Loading the numbers…
—times the 1983 land's clearing rate, in the strip added by Bacurizinho's extension, during the study measured
—of the 2000 canopy lost: extension · 10 km around, Porquinhos measured
—of mapped British Columbia land is long-term Crown tenure (a share of mapped classes) measured
measured by satellite or from the geometry itself. registered as the official catalogue publishes it.
1
The question
Does who holds a forest change what happens to it, and how would we know? Here are two countries at the same scale, with tree cover as it was in 2000.
Result to look for: the two maps look alike in how green they are, yet the rules about who decides are written differently. What the maps do not say is who holds the land under each colour.
Question for the room: Before any number: what would you need to see to say that the holder, and not something else, made the difference?
2
Two ways of writing who decides
Question: who is written down as the holder? In Canada, the national forest inventory sorts forest land by ownership. In Brazil, the national register of public forests lists public forests by sphere of government. The two schemes are not the same, so the bars below are not a like-for-like comparison.
Meaning: most Canadian forest land is provincial Crown land. In the two Brazilian states shown, public forest is split between the Union and the state. What this does not mean: that public land is protected, or that private land is cleared.
Question for the room: Why might a country choose to hold most of its forest as public land, and what does that change for who can be held to account?
3
British Columbia: Crown land, licences, parks, private block
Question: what kinds of holder sit on the same landscape? Switch the layer to see the province's tenure classes, then two Tree Farm Licences and a block of private forest land.
Result: each holder has its own boundary, its own rules and its own record. This view maps public tenure, protection and private property only; it does not map Indigenous lands (see step 19).
Question for the room: If you managed one of these units, whom would you need to talk to before changing anything?
4
Brazil: the Union, states, municipalities, private
Question: how does the same exercise look in Brazil? Switch the layer: public forests designated or not, protected areas by sphere of government, and the registered rural properties around Paragominas, Pará.
Result: public forest comes in several spheres, and a patchwork of registered properties sits beside it. What this does not show: whether a registered property is regular. The registry is self-declared.
Question for the room: In which country would it be easier to find out who is responsible for one patch of forest? What would you check?
5
Public does not mean protected; written is not proven
Question: is a public forest a protected forest? The chart separates public forest that has a designation from the part still classed as a collected tract, with no designation, in two Brazilian states.
Meaning: public ownership and protection are different things. The same gap exists for rights: in both countries the law recognises Indigenous rights over land, and in Canada the courts later decided what proving title means.
This page cites those texts only as legal background. It does not map any Indigenous land in Canada.
Question for the room: What would you want to see on a map to tell a right on paper from a right in practice?
6
The rules differ for the same question
Question: who may decide what happens in a forest? Read the table by row. The answers are written in each country's constitution and laws, and by different levels of government.
Meaning: the same question (who can authorise cutting here?) has different answers on each side. This is law, not a finding of the satellite data.
Question for the room: Which row would be hardest to explain to a visitor from the other country?
7
How we compare: inside, a ring around it, further out
Question: how do we measure whether land inside a boundary behaves differently? Draw the boundary, then count cleared land inside it, in a ring 10 km around it, and further out, with the same ruler everywhere.
Result: three zones that never overlap, shown on the map for Bacurizinho in Maranhão. What this setup cannot do: tell us why the zones differ. It only counts.
Question for the room: What could make the inside different from the ring before any rule applies?
8
Bacurizinho: two lands, two extensions
Question: what is the case? Two Indigenous lands in Maranhão, Bacurizinho (Guajajara) and Porquinhos (Canela Apãnjekra), each listed twice in the national catalogue: the 1983 land and the extension that contains it.
Drag the bar to compare 1985 and 2025. Meaning: the old land lies wholly inside the extension, so inside and outside are not clean categories. This is why the strip added by the extension is counted on its own.
Question for the room: If the old land is inside the extension, what exactly is the comparison group?
9
A demarcation that stopped halfway
Question: what stage was each land in, and when? An Indigenous land in Brazil goes through study, delimitation, declaration, ratification and registration. The table gives the year of each phase in the catalogue.
Result: both extensions were studied and declared, and neither was ratified. What this does not say: why the process stopped. That is a matter for the administrative and court record.
Question for the room: What can happen on land that is declared but not yet marked on the ground?
10
Forty years of forest cover
Question: how much native vegetation was there, and how much is left? Move the slider through three years (1985, 2005, 2025); the 2008 image has its own step. The bars show the share of each zone that is native vegetation.
Meaning: the 1983 land changed little; the strip added by the extension lost far more. This is a description of the cover, not of its cause.
Question for the room: Would you expect the same pattern if the extension had been drawn somewhere else?
11
The 2008 image
Question: what was on the ground in 2008, the year the extension was declared and the cut-off year in Brazil's Forest Code? Drag the bar: on one side a 2008 satellite photograph, on the other the same place classified as land cover.
Result: the photograph shows openings and tracks that the classification turns into classes. What this does not show: who made them, or whether they were legal.
Question for the room: What can an image tell you that a classified map cannot, and the reverse?
12
The result: the strip against the old land
Question: was clearing different inside the old land than in the strip added to it, and when? Each line is primary clearing per 1,000 ha of its own zone, year by year. Hover over a line for values; hover the zones on the map.
Result: clearing in the strip rose after the extension began to be studied and kept rising after it was declared. What this does not say: that the extension caused it, or that the boundary would have prevented it.
Question for the room: Where would you expect clearing to start on this map, and why?
13
Where each patch of land ended up
Question: what did the land cover turn into between 1985 and 2025? A Sankey diagram shows where land went: the bars on the left are the land cover in 1985, the bars on the right the land cover in 2025, and each band is the area that moved from one to the other. Hover over a band to read its area.
Result: switch between the 1983 land, the strip added by the extension and the 10 km ring. What this does not say: why a patch changed, or who changed it.
Question for the room: Which band surprises you most, and what would you want to know about it?
14
A second measure of the same gap
Question: does a different measure agree? Tree-cover loss since 2001, from any cause, comes from a different dataset than land-cover classes.
Result: both measures point the same way. Read as one whole polygon with the old land inside, the figure is close to the 1.75 to 1.91 ratio found in earlier test runs of a doctoral project. The match is a check, not a proof of cause.
Question for the room: If two measures agree, what does that rule out, and what does it leave open?
15
Porquinhos: the opposite pattern
Question: does the same reading hold on the neighbouring land? At Porquinhos, the extension is almost three times the old land and was declared two years after Bacurizinho's.
Result: here the extension lost more canopy than the 10 km around it, the opposite of what a simple tenure effect would suggest. Meaning: tenure alone does not predict the outcome.
Question for the room: What would you want to know about Porquinhos before judging the tenure?
16
Why might lands differ? Questions, not findings
This page does not explain the differences; the chart shows only what the data can say about the clearing. The candidate explanations below are questions to be looked up in the literature, each one testable in a different way:
Enforcement and monitoring, by communities and by public agencies: who watches, and who answers?
Legal exclusion: do titles, credit or permits differ inside the line?
Location: were Indigenous lands drawn where forest still stood and roads were far, so that less clearing would be expected anyway?
Boundary pressure: does the ring around a land carry more clearing because the land is next to it?
Rules versus practice: what people do on the ground is not in a land-cover map.
To be looked up, with citations, before they are called results.
Question for the room: Pick one explanation: what data would you need to test it, and who holds that data?
17
Protected areas are tenure too
Question: do two parks in the same state, one federal and one state, follow the same history? Choose the park and the year, or the terms of office; the chart shows primary clearing per 1,000 ha inside each park.
Result: the federal park's clearing rose and fell with the federal term, while the state governor stayed the same. What this does not say: why. Enforcement, prices and weather also changed.
Question for the room: What would make you trust a term-of-office comparison, and what would make you doubt it?
18
Fire is not clearing
Question: is a burned area a cleared area? The charts show the share burned each year at West Kelowna and in the Cerrado window; switch the map between West Kelowna in British Columbia, 2023, and Porquinhos in the Brazilian cerrado.
Result: at West Kelowna the 2023 fire shows as a spike of lost tree cover in a single year. In the cerrado, burning is part of the landscape's cycle, protected or not. What this means: a map of fire needs a different reading than a map of clearing.
Question for the room: How would a forest manager tell a fire the forest needs from a fire it does not?
19
Why there is no Canadian First Nations map here
Canadian First Nations lands are not analysed in this story. The principles of OCAP (ownership, control, access and possession) say that a First Nation owns and controls information about its people, lands and resources, and decides who collects, keeps and uses it. Public data about a community is not the same as the community's consent to be analysed.
A community-led version would need: a request or an agreement from the Nation; the Nation deciding the question and the measures; the Nation holding the data and reviewing the results before anything is shown; and agreed credit and use. We have none of this, so we show none.
Question for the room: Who should decide which data about a First Nation's land are collected, kept and shown, and what does that change about how you use maps?
20
What a cover map cannot see
Question: is a forest that looks intact on the map intact? A cover map sees canopy, not what lives under it. Selective logging, collecting, hunting and disease leave the forest class unchanged.
Example from the Atlantic Forest in Espírito Santo, from another story on this site: species counts say as much about where people collected as about biology. Bacurizinho's species are not mapped here; that would be a question to look up.
Question for the room: What would you need to measure, on the ground, to know a forest is intact?
21
Where every number came from
Every number on this page comes from data files already published with other stories on this site. One calculation was added for the lecture: the 1985 to 2025 land-cover transitions of the 10 km ring around Bacurizinho (step 13), run once with the same service as the other zones.
The table lists the sources and which story each one came from.
Question for the room: Pick a number from this page: could you trace it back to its source file?
umaterra.com.br · forest tenure lecture
…
Loading the numbers…
What this story does not say
It does not say that tenure causes less clearing. Indigenous lands are often drawn where forest still stands and far from roads, which would lower clearing with no tenure effect at all.
Inside and outside are not clean at Bacurizinho. The old land lies inside the extension, so the strip is counted on its own and the ring is only a rough comparison.
Porquinhos shows the opposite pattern. A single case, or a pair, is not a rule.
The match to the published ratio is a check, not a proof. It comes from test runs, not from a peer-reviewed result.
It cannot see below 30 m. Small swiddens and selective logging under the canopy escape both maps.
It says nothing about Canadian First Nations land. That is deliberate (step 19).
Written with Claude, by Anthropic, from numbers already computed for other stories on this site: no number comes from the model. Versão em português.
Notes
Hansen, M. C. et al. (2013). High-resolution global maps of 21st-century forest cover change. Science 342, 850–853. doi:10.1126/science.1244693. Tree cover in the year 2000.
Brazil. Constitution of 1988, arts. 20 II; 26 IV; 225 § 4 (unclaimed lands of the Union and the states).
Brazil. Law 12,651/2012 (Forest Code), art. 17: the Legal Reserve duty falls on the owner, possessor or occupant, public or private.
Canada. Constitution Acts, 1867 to 1982, s. 92(5) and s. 92A(1)(b): provincial management of public lands and timber, and of forestry resources. laws-lois.justice.gc.ca.
British Columbia. Land Act, RSBC 1996, c. 245, s. 1 (Crown land); Forest Act, RSBC 1996, c. 157, s. 1(1) (Crown timber). Tenure layers: CPCAD (ECCC), BC FADM_TFL, parcel fabric; Open Government Licence – BC and – Canada. The private block is a stand-in rebuilt from parcels of 100 ha or more, not the official list.
Brazil. Constitution of 1988, art. 231, caput (legal background only; no Indigenous land is mapped).
Canada. Constitution Act, 1982, s. 35(1) (legal background only).
Supreme Court of Canada. Delgamuukw v. British Columbia, [1997] 3 SCR 1010 (legal background).
Supreme Court of Canada. Tsilhqot'in Nation v. British Columbia, 2014 SCC 44, paras. 73 and 116 (legal background).
Natural Resources Canada. The State of Canada's Forests: Annual Report 2024, forest ownership (NFI 2017 remeasurement). The categories listed sum to 97.9%; the rest belongs to a category not quoted here.
Brazilian Forest Service. Public Forest Management Report 2025 and CNFP 2025 (dados.florestal.gov.br); sums by sphere are ours. SICAR/CAR properties are self-declared and not validated. MMA, CNUC.
The catalogue lists both versions of each land under their own codes; the 1983 land lies wholly inside its extension. FUNAI, catalogue of Indigenous lands, as Yvynation publishes it. The 1.75 to 1.91 range comes from test runs by Biondo, L. M. for a PhD project at UBC Okanagan (proposal, 2025), compared there with the range in Pfaff and Robalino (2017); not independently verified here.
MapBiomas Brazil, Collection 11 (30 m): land cover and primary deforestation (the year a native-vegetation pixel first turns to farm use).
Google LLC, Brazil Forest Imagery Dataset 2008 (SPOT, 5 to 10 m); Law 12,651/2012, art. 3, IV (cut-off of 22 July 2008).
Provisional Measure 758/2016, turned into Law 13,452/2017, changed the limits of Jamanxim National Park (STF, ADI 6553). Clearing: MapBiomas Collection 11; fire: MapBiomas Fire.
Data from the story on the Mello Leitão Biology Museum (Espírito Santo): GBIF.org records by species and municipality.