Exploratory: generated automatically from the UmaTerra platforms' data; not independently validated or peer reviewed.

UmaTerra · story Português
Forest · tenure and law · Brazil · Canada

Who decides about the forest: tenure, rules and the right to cut in Brazil and Canada

Who owns the forest, who makes the rules and who may cut it, read side by side in Brazil (Pará, Maranhão, Paraná and Espírito Santo) and in British Columbia: public tenure, protection and private property, with the laws cited, maps at the same scale and the numbers the data return. This is a report showing how the data can be used, not a peer-reviewed publication.

How to cite: Biondo, Leandro M. (2026). Who decides about the forest: tenure, rules and the right to cut in Brazil and Canada. UmaTerra. https://umaterra.com.br/en/stories/forests-who-decides/

Loading the numbers…

—million hectares of public forest in the four study states (CNFP 2025, without Indigenous lands) measured
—% of Canada's forest is public (provincial, territorial, federal and municipal), by the State of Canada's Forests 2024 scheme measured
—places read closely, of public tenure, protection and private property measured

measured by satellite, official outline, cadastre or count; or statute text with its note. estimated a reading that depends on a choice or on a self-declared cadastre. missing a part that was not done.

Why look at Brazil and Canada

Two of the world's largest forests. More than half of the world's forests (54%) are in five countries: Russia, Brazil, Canada, the United States and China. Brazil has 497 million hectares of forest, 12% of the world total, and Canada has 347 million, 9%. Together they hold about a fifth of the planet's forests (FAO, 2020). What each one decides about protecting, cutting or restoring forest matters far beyond its borders.

Climate. Forests take carbon out of the air: on average 1.1 billion tonnes of carbon a year, roughly one-sixth of fossil fuel emissions (Pan et al., 2011). That balance can change. In the Amazon, measurements linked the forest's shift to a carbon source to deforestation and climate change (Gatti et al., 2021). In British Columbia, a mountain pine beetle outbreak was studied as a forest carbon feedback to climate (Kurz et al., 2008).

Protecting and restoring biomass. The boreal forest, which covers much of Canada, is one of the largest biomes on Earth, and about two-thirds of its area is under some form of management, mostly for wood production (Gauthier et al., 2015). In Brazil, restoring is part of the answer: secondary forests of the American tropics build biomass back (Poorter et al., 2016), and the much-reduced Atlantic Forest is treated as a restoration opportunity (Rezende et al., 2018).

Water. Forest is also water. Trees return moisture to the air, and that moisture becomes rain somewhere else (Ellison et al., 2017); in the Amazon, the rain the forest recycles helps buffer droughts (Staal et al., 2018). In British Columbia, the valleys' water depends on the snow that builds up in the mountains, the subject of another story.

How the places were chosen. The places are not a random sample and do not represent the two countries. The choice was partly arbitrary and partly guided by similarities. The regions came first: British Columbia, because forest law in Canada is provincial and that is where the tools and the open data reach furthest; Pará and Maranhão, for the Amazon and its forest concessions; Paraná and Espírito Santo, for the Atlantic Forest. Inside them we looked for one place of each tenure type (public production forest, protected area and private land), preferably near places the portal had already studied, such as the state capitals and the Okanagan. We then paired them by tenure type, not by biome or size: a national forest with a concession beside a licence to cut on public land, a reserve beside a park, a mosaic of properties beside a block of private land. The pairs differ in size, climate and forest; what they share is the question of who decides. Other places would give other numbers.

What the two stories do. This series does not measure carbon or water. It shows, in the same places of both countries, who decides about the forest and what the satellite recorded and what is ahead. The numbers in this box come from the sources cited below, not from our own measurements.

Sources for this box: FAO (2020). Global Forest Resources Assessment 2020: Key findings. doi:10.4060/ca8753en; Pan et al. (2011). A large and persistent carbon sink in the world’s forests. Science. doi:10.1126/science.1201609; Gatti et al. (2021). Amazonia as a carbon source linked to deforestation and climate change. Nature. doi:10.1038/s41586-021-03629-6; Kurz et al. (2008). Mountain pine beetle and forest carbon feedback to climate change. Nature. doi:10.1038/nature06777; Gauthier et al. (2015). Boreal forest health and global change. Science. doi:10.1126/science.aaa9092; Poorter et al. (2016). Biomass resilience of Neotropical secondary forests. Nature. doi:10.1038/nature16512; Rezende et al. (2018). From hotspot to hopespot: An opportunity for the Brazilian Atlantic Forest. Perspectives in Ecology and Conservation. doi:10.1016/j.pecon.2018.10.002; Ellison et al. (2017). Trees, forests and water: Cool insights for a hot world. Global Environmental Change. doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2017.01.002; Staal et al. (2018). Forest-rainfall cascades buffer against drought across the Amazon. Nature Climate Change. doi:10.1038/s41558-018-0177-y.

1

Brazil and Canada, at the same scale

Both maps show tree cover in the year 2000, with the same legend and at the same scale: 30 m pixels with —% canopy or more. Each country's area is computed from its polygon: tree cover occupies —% of Brazil and —% of Canada.

The story starts there for a question the map alone cannot answer: whose forest it is, who makes the rules and who may cut it.

2

Forest is not only the Amazon

IBGE divides the territory into six biomes. Inside each biome polygon the share with tree cover varies widely: —% in the Amazon, —% in the Atlantic Forest and —% in the Cerrado.

3

In Canada, forest follows the ecozones

The Canadian equivalent is the ecozone. Each ecozone has a different forested share, and British Columbia is highlighted because it is the province the story reads closely: —% of the province has tree cover in 2000.

4

One province and four states

Each region has a window of — by — km, at the same scale in all three pairs: British Columbia; Pará with Maranhão; Paraná with Espírito Santo. The places read closely lie inside them.

The pairs are not twins: they are tenure types that can be set side by side, public production, protection and private property.

5

What the vegetation was, not what it is today

The IBGE vegetation map for the four states (PA, MA, PR and ES) shows each polygon's original vegetation type, read through the superclass and the first legend. It is not a cover map: a dense ombrophilous forest polygon may be pasture today.

The area classified as predominantly anthropic is —% of the four states together.

6

Forest classes in 2022

The 2022 NTEMS VLCE2 annual map separates the province's cover classes. The forest class totals — ha, —% of the province. The map ends in 2022: it is the latest year the story can show for Canada.

7

Public does not mean protected

The law calls a forest public when it stands on assets of the Union, the states, the municipalities, the Federal District or the indirect administration. In the four study states, the National Cadastre of Public Forests adds up to — million hectares (sum by row, without Indigenous lands): — federal, — state and — municipal.

Part has a destination (conservation unit, concession, community use) and part has none: at the federal level — million hectares are designated and — are not; at state level, — and —. The map shows both classes in Pará and Maranhão, without drawing Indigenous lands.

8

The Union, states and municipalities also create forests

A conservation unit is created by an act of the public power, federal, state or municipal. In the units that touch the four study states, the national cadastre holds — units: — federal, — state and — municipal (our sums of the file).

A National Forest is under public possession and domain; created by a state or municipality it is called a State or Municipal Forest. In the study's four states the map separates the units by sphere, and Maranhão enters only here, with the Gurupi Biological Reserve and the Cururupu Extractive Reserve.

9

In the Paragominas window, a mosaic of properties

Private rural property shows up in the Rural Environmental Registry, where each owner declares the property. In the Paragominas window there are — registered properties, with a median of — ha and a maximum of — ha; the largest —% hold —% of the area.

The registry is self-declared and the drawing is simplified to 12 m: it serves to see the mosaic's pattern, not to measure a fine boundary, nor to say who holds the title.

10

Almost all of it is public, and provincial

According to the federal government, about 94% of the country's forest is public: 90% provincial or territorial, 4% federal and 6% private. Another class scheme, from the report on Canada's forests, adds ownership up differently, which is why the story always says which scheme it uses.

In British Columbia about 94% of the territory is Crown land and about 95% of the timber is publicly owned; the government grants the right to harvest through tenures.

11

Parks, TFLs and the private block

The map sets three tenure types of the province side by side: parks (CPCAD), two Tree Farm Licences (TFL 49 and TFL 56) and a block of private forest land. The block was rebuilt from the parcel fabric (private parcels of 100 ha or more), with First Nations overlaps removed (— ha), and carries the descriptive label “Managed forest land”: it is a stand-in, not the list of lands under the private forest land act.

12

Who owns the forest, in writing

In Brazil the Constitution places among the Union's assets the unclaimed lands indispensable to environmental preservation and gives the states the unclaimed lands that are not the Union's; the Amazon Forest and the Atlantic Forest are national heritage, which is a condition of use, not a form of ownership. The duty to keep the Legal Reserve falls on the owner, possessor or occupant, public or private.

In Canada the Constitution Act gives the provinces the management and sale of provincial public lands and of the timber on them, and exclusive power over the development, conservation and management of forestry resources. In British Columbia, Crown land is land or an interest in land vested in the government, and Crown timber is the timber on it.

13

A right written down is not a right proven

Both countries recognise in law the rights of Indigenous peoples over land, and that is the legal background of tenure. In Brazil the Constitution says Indigenous peoples hold original rights over the lands they traditionally occupy, and the Union must demarcate them. In Canada the Constitution recognises and affirms existing Aboriginal and treaty rights.

In Canada the difference between writing and proving went through the courts: in Delgamuukw, Aboriginal title is a right to the land itself; in Tsilhqot'in, established title carries the rights of an owner, including deciding how the land is used, and the timber stops being “Crown timber”. This story does not map Indigenous lands or First Nations data: both countries have their own rules for such data, and the maps keep to public tenure, protection and private property.

14

Three levels, drawn in different ways

In Brazil the Union, states, Federal District and municipalities share the common competence to protect the environment and preserve forests, fauna and flora. Legislative competence over forests is concurrent: the Union stays with general norms, the states supplement them, and without a federal law the states have full power; the municipality legislates on matters of local interest and supplements federal and state law.

In Canada forestry is a provincial matter, and the step's table sets side by side, by level, what each country assigns to the Union or federal government, to the states or province and to the municipality.

15

Complementary Law 140, in three spheres

Complementary Law 140/2011 regulates cooperation among the entities. The Union licenses, among others, projects on Indigenous lands, in federal conservation units (except APAs) and in two or more states, and approves suppression and management in federal public forests, federal unclaimed lands and those units.

States approve suppression and management in state public forests, state units and rural properties, and hold the residual competence; municipalities license activities of local impact and approve management in municipal forests and units. The four-state map shows which sphere answers for each unit.

16

The rule changes with the line on the map

The percentage of Legal Reserve that a rural property keeps depends on whether it lies in the Legal Amazon and, inside it, on the vegetation type: 80% in forest areas, 35% in cerrado and 20% in campos gerais; elsewhere in the country, 20%. It is not a rule by biome.

The law defines the Legal Amazon by the Northern states and Mato Grosso and by parts of Tocantins, Goiás and Maranhão, Maranhão being the part west of the 44° W meridian. The map carries the Legal Amazon outline, that meridian and the four states: Pará and the western part of Maranhão fall under the Amazon rule; Paraná and Espírito Santo, under the 20% rule.

17

Why the story reads only British Columbia

Canadian forests are regulated by provincial laws: each province has its own, and the story reads only one, British Columbia, to compare with four Brazilian states without mixing different laws. Other provinces would have other rules and other numbers.

The federal government reaches the forest through other laws: the Fisheries Act prohibits harmful alteration, disruption or destruction of fish habitat; the Species at Risk Act protects critical habitat on federal land; and national parks have ecological integrity as their first priority.

18

The municipality, in Brazil and in Canada

In Brazil the municipality legislates on matters of local interest and supplements federal and state law, and licenses activities of local impact and those in its conservation units.

In British Columbia a municipal council may regulate trees by bylaw, but the bylaw does not apply to land whose forest practices are governed by a TFL or another Forest Act tenure, nor to private managed forest land under its own act.

19

The chain from law to chainsaw

In Brazil clearing for alternative land use requires CAR registration and prior authorization from the state environmental-system body; in a federal public forest or federal unit it is the Union that approves suppression and management; for forest concessions, the granting authority is the Brazilian Forest Service, which signs the contracts.

In British Columbia the right to harvest Crown timber is granted only under the Forest Act; a holder of a forestry agreement needs an approved forest stewardship plan before cutting; and the Chief Forester determines the allowable annual cut. The step's table sets the two chains side by side.

20

Twelve management units in four National Forests

A forest concession is the onerous delegation of the right to practise sustainable forest management in a management unit, by tender and for a fixed term. The unit is georeferenced and entered in the public-forest cadastre, and the concessionaire gets only the rights the contract gives, with no right to the land.

In Pará the Brazilian Forest Service publishes the polygons of — units in — National Forests.

21

Two concessions of different sizes and years

The two National Forests are read side by side at the same scale. The Caxiuanã National Forest has — ha and — ha in management units, —% of the forest; the contracts were signed in —. Saracá-Taquera has — ha and — ha conceded, —%; its contracts date from —. Next to it lies the Rio Trombetas Biological Reserve, under strict protection.

What public data allow is only this: two concessions of different size, conceded share and contract year. Who profits more is not published per unit, and the public indicators point in different directions: the payment to the granting authority in 2025 was R$ — million in Caxiuanã and R$ — million in Saracá-Taquera; the contract log price, R$ — and R$ — per m³; the volume moved changed order from one year to the next, and both owe money to the Forest Service. A payment to the granting authority is not profit.

The distances measured on OpenStreetMap follow the same rule of not concluding: from the Forest's edge to Belém they are — km for Caxiuanã and — km for Saracá-Taquera; to the nearest town, — km and — km.

22

Forty years at most

The concession contract lasts at least one harvest cycle and at most 40 years. Law 14,590 of 24 May 2023 converts Provisional Measure 1,151/2022 and amends Law 11,284; among the changes, a concession may also cover forest restoration.

The maps of the previous step show the units whose contracts follow these rules.

23

TFL 49 and TFL 56

A Tree Farm Licence (TFL) is one of the tenure forms through which British Columbia grants the right to harvest Crown timber. TFL 49 has — ha and TFL 56 has — ha, read from the open boundary layers. The holder of TFL 49 is —; TFL 56 is held by Revelstoke Community Forest Corporation, a corporation set up by the City of Revelstoke.

24

What was authorized, by holder

The authorized cutblocks, from the open forest-tenure layer, show where each holder has an approved cut inside the two TFLs: — blocks in TFL 49 and — in TFL 56. The layer carries the holder's name, and the story does not mix it with the consolidated harvest history, which has a different licence.

25

How much may be cut per year, and who decides

The Chief Forester determines the allowable annual cut (AAC) of each timber supply area and each TFL at least every 10 years, which may be postponed up to 15 years with written reasons; for woodlots, community forests and First Nations woodland licences the AAC is set by the minister, according to the agreement. In the determination the Chief Forester considers the sustained rate of timber production, forest composition, silviculture and non-timber constraints.

The provincial total in force since 15 September 2026 is 55.29 million m³ a year: 44.37 million in timber supply areas and 10.92 million in TFLs. The stumpage rate, the price of Crown timber, is set by a ministry employee, and unauthorized cutting pays stumpage plus other amounts. The most recent TFL 49 determination is on the government's page.

26

On private land, the right to cut is the owner's

In British Columbia, private managed forest land is private land with a management commitment, the specific act does not apply in TFLs, woodlots and community forests; a local government must not restrict, directly or indirectly, a management activity on that land, and regulation rests with the provincial council set up by that act. The block on the map, however, is a stand-in: it is not the list of those lands.

In Brazil a private property keeps the Legal Reserve, which may be exploited by sustainable management approved beforehand by the environmental body, for own use or commercially; the pattern of properties in Paragominas is the one in step 9.

27

From 1985 to the latest map, inside and within 10 km

The slider moves between 1985 and the latest year of each map: MapBiomas Collection 11 (to 2025) in Brazil and NTEMS VLCE2 (to 2022) in Canada, each with its own legend. The white outline is the unit; the ring is 10 km wide.

In Caxiuanã the forest class went from —% to —% of the unit; in TFL 49, from —% to —%. TFL 49 is small in the common window: that is information too.

28

Cover year by year in the two units

The chart adds up the area of each class by year in the same units, from each map with its own legend: a MapBiomas class is never added to an NTEMS one. The Canadian series ends in — and the Brazilian one in —.

29

The Pará contrast enters the pair

The same reading, now with Saracá-Taquera and the Rio Trombetas Biological Reserve beside it, and TFL 56, in windows of — by — km. In the Saracá-Taquera unit forest is —% in 1985 and —% in the latest map; in TFL 56, —% and —%.

30

Two protected areas, at different scales

Note: the two panels use different boxes and rulers. The Rio Trombetas Biological Reserve is read in a box of — km and the Okanagan Mountain Provincial Park in one of — km, because the areas are — ha and — ha.

In Canada a provincial park is managed by the province; in Brazil the biological reserve belongs to the units that the national system's bodies administer, each in its sphere.

31

Cover year by year in the two protected areas

The chart reads like step 28's: separate legends, series ending in different years. Inside the Rio Trombetas Biological Reserve forest is —% in the latest map; in Okanagan Mountain, —%.

32

Two private landscapes, at different scales

Here too the boxes differ: the Paragominas window is — km and the “Managed forest land” block (a descriptive label, a stand-in) is — km. In Paragominas land use is read from MapBiomas inside the window of registered properties; in the block, from NTEMS.

33

Cover year by year in the two landscapes

In the Paragominas window forest is —% in 1985 and —% in the latest map; in the “Managed forest land” block, —% and —%. The two cut-outs are not the same kind of property: one is a mosaic of registered properties and the other a descriptive stand-in.

34

Two pieces of a heavily cut forest

The Sooretama Biological Reserve (ES) and the Irati National Forest (PR), side by side, show the Atlantic Forest under two protection spheres, in a window of — km. In the Atlantic Forest, clearing primary or advanced-stage vegetation is authorized by the state body and as a rule is allowed only for public-utility works; Irati National Forest has had one management unit conceded (UMF I), with a 2024 contract.

This is the forest that other stories read closely: Mello Leitão, in Santa Teresa, Three parks, Campos Gerais and Guartelá and Jamanxim and Martírios; here we only link to them.

35

When each unit got its regime

Each unit has its own timeline: creation, contract signing, tenure award and change of statute. The dates come from cadastres and contracts, not from the text: — events in — units.

The methodological question the timeline leaves open is whether a change of government or statute alters what the maps show. This story only poses it; it computes nothing.

36

The limits, in a list

The story is a report showing how the data can be used; it is not a peer-reviewed publication. The limits are listed at the end of the page: one province only; no Indigenous lands and no First Nations data, in either country, for the same reason; different legends that are never added; the CAR is self-declared and simplified; the E&N block is a stand-in; and the nature of the TFL 56 holder comes only from the government's release.

37

Each place, in the right app

The same places can be read in Yvynation (conservation units and land use), in Naturametrics (a point, by rings) and in Camposcope (the CAR property and its surroundings). The map's buttons lead to each.

38

Fire and climate, in another story

The same places are seen from the other side of the question, fire and climate, in the second story of the series: What the satellite saw and what is ahead. Forest loss, fire and drivers are not included here.

umaterra.com.br · Who decides about the forest
Loading…measured
Loading the numbers…

What this story does not say

Read next: What the satellite saw and what is ahead

Written with Claude, from Anthropic, from the laws cited and the numbers the data returned: no fact or number comes from the model. Português.

Notes and references

  1. Hansen, M. C. et al. (2013). High-resolution global maps of 21st-century forest cover change. Science 342, 850–853. doi:10.1126/science.1244693. Tree cover in the year 2000 (treecover2000), 30 m pixels.
  2. IBGE. Maps of biomes, natural vegetation domains and regions, and vegetation (scale 1:250,000), in SIRGAS 2000, clipped to the IBGE state boundaries. The vegetation field describes the original vegetation of each type, not the present cover. ibge.gov.br.
  3. Terrestrial ecozones of Canada, a layer held in the Camposcope cache, used only as a reading frame (the province outline is not published).
  4. Hermosilla, T. et al. (2018). Disturbance-informed annual land cover classification maps of Canada's forested ecosystems for a 29-year (1984–2012) period. Canadian Journal of Remote Sensing 44, 67–87. doi:10.1080/07038992.2018.1437719; NTEMS VLCE2 product (1984 to 2022), Open Government Licence – Canada. Contains information licensed under the Open Government Licence – Canada.
  5. Brazil. Law 11,284 of 2 March 2006 (public-forest management), arts. 3 I and 14 sole paragraph (National Cadastre of Public Forests). Text checked in a copy of 14 Jan 2025 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  6. Brazilian Forest Service. Public Forest Management Report 2025, Table 1 (CNFP 2025). Read on 15 Nov 2026. www.gov.br.
  7. Brazil. Law 9,985 of 18 July 2000 (SNUC), arts. 17 §§ 1 and 6, and 22. Text checked in a copy of 19 Dec 2024 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  8. MMA (Brazil). National Cadastre of Conservation Units, 2nd half of 2025, file cnuc_2025_08.csv; the counts by sphere are our own sums of the file. Read on 15 Nov 2026. dados.mma.gov.br.
  9. SICAR/CAR, state databases of registered rural properties (ES, MA, PA and PR), copied into our own table; geometries simplified to 12 m and declared by the owner, not validated. The text speaks of registered properties, never of regular or irregular ones.
  10. Natural Resources Canada. Forest land ownership, web page 'Forest land ownership', modified 28 Nov 2025: 90% provincial or territorial, 4% federal (includes Aboriginal land, national parks and defence), 6% private. Read on 15 Nov 2026. natural-resources.canada.ca.
  11. Natural Resources Canada. The State of Canada's Forests: Annual Report 2024, forest-ownership section; a different class scheme, based on the national forest inventory remeasured in 2017. Read on 15 Nov 2026. prod-natural-resources.azure.cloud.nrcan-rncan.gc.ca.
  12. British Columbia. Forestry (gov.bc.ca), forestry page (94% of the province is Crown land). Read on 15 Nov 2026. www2.gov.bc.ca.
  13. British Columbia. Forest Tenures (gov.bc.ca), Forest Tenures page, updated 15 Sep 2026 (about 95% of the province's timber is publicly owned). Read on 15 Nov 2026. www2.gov.bc.ca.
  14. Environment and Climate Change Canada, Canadian Protected and Conserved Areas Database (CPCAD), Open Government Licence – Canada. open.canada.ca.
  15. Contains information licensed under the Open Government Licence – British Columbia (TFL boundaries, FADM_TFL; authorized cutblocks, FTEN_CUT_BLOCK_POLY_SVW; parcel fabric, PMBC_PARCEL_FABRIC_POLY_SVW) and the Open Government Licence – Canada (CPCAD protected areas; NRCan). The E&N block was rebuilt from the parcel fabric and has First Nations overlaps subtracted in memory; no First Nations geometry is published, only the area removed.
  16. Brazil. Constitution of the Federative Republic of Brazil, 1988, arts. 20 II; 26 IV; 225 § 4. Text checked in a copy of 30 Dec 2024 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  17. Brazil. Law 12,651 of 25 May 2012 (Forest Code), art. 17 caput. Text checked in a copy of 12 Jan 2025 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  18. Canada. Constitution Acts, 1867 to 1982, s. 92(5) and s. 92A(1)(b). Read on 15 Nov 2026. laws-lois.justice.gc.ca.
  19. British Columbia. Land Act, RSBC 1996, c. 245, s. 1 (Crown land); Forest Act, RSBC 1996, c. 157, s. 1(1) (Crown timber). Read on 15 Nov 2026. www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca.
  20. Brazil. Constitution of the Federative Republic of Brazil, 1988, art. 231, caput (cited only as legal background; no Indigenous land is mapped). Text checked in a copy of 30 Dec 2024 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  21. Canada. Constitution Acts, 1867 to 1982, Constitution Act, 1982, s. 35(1) (cited only as legal background). Read on 15 Nov 2026. laws-lois.justice.gc.ca.
  22. Supreme Court of Canada. Delgamuukw v. British Columbia, [1997] 3 SCR 1010, reasons of Lamer C.J. (legal background). Read on 15 Nov 2026. decisions.scc-csc.ca.
  23. Supreme Court of Canada. Tsilhqot'in Nation v. British Columbia, 2014 SCC 44, paragraphs 73 and 116 (legal background). Read on 15 Nov 2026. decisions.scc-csc.ca.
  24. Brazil. Constitution of the Federative Republic of Brazil, 1988, arts. 23 VI and VII; 24 VI and §§ 1 to 3; 30 I and II. Text checked in a copy of 30 Dec 2024 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  25. Brazil. Complementary Law 140 of 8 December 2011, title and arts. 7 (XIV, XV), 8 (XIV, XVI) and 9 (XIV, XV). Text checked in a copy of 30 Dec 2024 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  26. Brazil. Law 12,651 of 25 May 2012 (Forest Code), art. 3 I (Legal Amazon) and art. 12 I and II (text of Law 12,727/2012). Text checked in a copy of 12 Jan 2025 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  27. Canada. Constitution Acts, 1867 to 1982 and the federal acts cited, s. 92A(2)–(3); Fisheries Act, s. 35(1); Species at Risk Act, ss. 2(1), 34(1), 58(1); Canada National Parks Act, ss. 4(1) and 8(2). Read on 15 Nov 2026. laws-lois.justice.gc.ca.
  28. British Columbia. Community Charter, SBC 2003, c. 26, ss. 8(3)(c) and 50(1). Read on 15 Nov 2026. www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca.
  29. Brazil. Law 12,651 of 25 May 2012 (Forest Code), art. 26. Text checked in a copy of 12 Jan 2025 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  30. Brazil. Law 11,284 of 2 March 2006 (public-forest management), arts. 3 VII (wording of Law 14,590/2023), 4, 14, 16 and 35. Text checked in a copy of 14 Jan 2025 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  31. British Columbia. Forest Act, RSBC 1996, c. 157, ss. 11 and 12(1). Read on 15 Nov 2026. www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca.
  32. British Columbia. Forest and Range Practices Act, SBC 2002, c. 69, s. 3(1). Read on 15 Nov 2026. www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca.
  33. British Columbia. Forest Act, RSBC 1996, c. 157, ss. 8(1), 8(3.1), 8(6)–(8)(a), 103(3) and 105(1). Read on 15 Nov 2026. www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca.
  34. Brazilian Forest Service, ArcGIS layers Limites_UMFs and unidades_concessoes_florestais (forest management unit polygons), read on 15 Nov 2026; areas computed from the polygon in an equal-area projection (ESRI:102033); the SFB area field was not used. Contracts, signing dates and volumes: SFB open data (CSV, CC-BY) and the Public Forest Management Report 2025, tables 5, 6, 7, 22 and 25.
  35. Lima, F. B. de. Determinantes da viabilidade financeira no investimento em concessões florestais (Determinants of financial viability in forest-concession investment). VII SFB Prize (ENAP), 1st place, professional category: the only public financial model of units in these concessions, with data from one company per National Forest (Ebata in Saracá-Taquera, 2012 to 2017; Cemal in Caxiuanã, 2018 only). Not a direct comparison: it only warns that the result depended on volume per hectare and on selling logs.
  36. OpenStreetMap, via Overpass, on 15 Nov 2026 (roads, rivers, ports and sawmills); straight-line distances, measured from the edges and from the centroid. OSM is volunteered and incomplete in the Amazon and carries no navigability: the distances say what is mapped, not what a freight run costs. openstreetmap.org/copyright.
  37. Brazil. Law 14,590 of 24 May 2023, title (conversion of MP 1,151/2022; amends Law 11,284). Text checked in a copy of 13 Jan 2025 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  38. Government of British Columbia, news release 2021FLNRO0032-000836: “TFL 56 is held by the Revelstoke Community Forest Corporation”. The holder's corporate nature was not read in a primary registry; the text repeats only the release's sentence and what the corporation is according to local press: a company set up by the City of Revelstoke. news.gov.bc.ca.
  39. British Columbia. Provincial Summary Report (apportionment 2026/27), report APTR032, effective 15 Sep 2026 (TSAs 44,370,011 m³ and TFLs 10,917,287 m³). Read on 15 Nov 2026. www2.gov.bc.ca.
  40. British Columbia. Timber Supply Review and Allowable Annual Cut (gov.bc.ca), page lists the latest TFL 49 determination (21 Nov 2025); example of a determination: TFL 46, effective 28 May 2024. Read on 15 Nov 2026. www2.gov.bc.ca.
  41. British Columbia. Private Managed Forest Land Act, SBC 2003, c. 80, ss. 1, 3, 5 and 21. Read on 15 Nov 2026. www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca.
  42. British Columbia. Private Managed Forest Land Act, SBC 2003, c. 80, ss. 3, 5 and 21. Read on 15 Nov 2026. www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca.
  43. Brazil. Law 12,651 of 25 May 2012 (Forest Code), arts. 17 § 1 and 20. Text checked in a copy of 12 Jan 2025 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  44. Souza, C. M. et al. (2020). Reconstructing three decades of land use and land cover changes in Brazilian biomes with Landsat archive and Earth Engine. Remote Sensing 12, 2735. doi:10.3390/rs12172735; MapBiomas Project, Collection 11 (1985 to 2025), mapbiomas.org.
  45. Brazil. Law 9,985 of 18 July 2000 (SNUC), art. 6 III (executing bodies). Text checked in a copy of 19 Dec 2024 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  46. Brazil. Law 11,428 of 22 December 2006 (Atlantic Forest), arts. 1 and 14 §§ 1 and 2. Text checked in a copy of 19 Dec 2024 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  47. Brazil. Law 11,428 of 22 December 2006 (Atlantic Forest), arts. 14 caput and 20. Text checked in a copy of 19 Dec 2024 (Wayback Machine, Planalto page); re-check in a browser before quoting. web.archive.org.
  48. Brazilian Forest Service. Public Forest Management Report 2025, Quadro 3 (concessions in force in 2025: Irati National Forest, UMF I). Read on 15 Nov 2026. www.gov.br.